A feud between neighbors has led the Michigan Court of Appeals to rule rude comments alone are not enough to grant a personal protection order or PPO.
The court says the issue arose when one neighbor said, “Here come your masser,” as a white neighbor tried to intervene during a dispute.
Both feuding neighbors are Black…and a lower court deemed the remark hate speech and granted a protection order in the case.
Attorney Kevin Gentry represented the woman who made the remark. He says PPOs are only for keeping people safe from threats.
“If people could get a PPO because they didn’t like one another or because they said bad things to one another, the courts would be rapidly clogged up with many, many, many PPOs because there are plenty of people in the world who don’t get along.” said Gentry.
The appellate court ruled the neighbor’s comment fell under the First Amendment’s free speech protections.